Although not infallible, learning some principles of body language can be helpful in determining if somebody is lying or not.
Much of human communication is non-verbal in nature. Kinesiology is the study of non-linguistic communication and is more commonly called body language. Body language is a type of communication consisting of many physiological elements ranging from body position to hand gestures to eye movements. Law enforcement and security professionals are often trained to employ techniques using the principles of body language in order to detect deception in a subject, however, just about anybody can easily learn the basic foundations of kinesiology. It is important to note that this science is based on principles and is not governed by hard and fast rules. Establishing a baseline of individual behavior is essential to being able to use these principles effectively. The study of body language assists people in making educated guesses about another person’s motives and/or behaviors and is not an exact science.
Common Signs of Deception
When an individual is practicing deception, inevitably they will manifest some signs of deceit in their physiology. In general, their physical expressions may be decreased or limited.
Arm and leg movements tend to be stifled and hand gestures are more subdued than normal. Gestures that are expressed will be directed more toward the liar’s own body.
A person who is lying may avoid extended eye contact with the person that they are being untruthful with and they may touch their face, mouth, ears, or neck more than usual.
Their timing may be noticeably “off” between their verbal delivery and emotional expression. For example, when receiving a gift a person may verbally express their feigned delight by saying, “I love it!” but their coinciding emotional response (a smile) will take place a split second after they said the words, whereas, if the words were genuinely true, the smile would have taken place simultaneously.
A more overt indication of deception is when the verbal and emotional expressions are obviously incongruent. For example, “I love it!” would be accompanied by a frown or grimace instead of a smile. Another more subtle example of incongruence would be a calm facial expression accompanied by fidgety feet or hands.
A liar will tend to be a bit uncomfortable in the presence of their accuser and may consequently position or turn their body or face away from the other person. They may also utilize physical barriers by unconsciously placing items like a coffee cup, a book or the deceiver’s own folded arms between them and the other person in a psychologically attempt to distance the deceiver from anyone who might question or accuse them.
A liar oftentimes will use the questioner’s own words in an exaggerated verbatim manner to answer questions. For example:
Questioner: “Were you at the scene of the crime last night.”
Liar: “No, I was not at the scene of the crime last night!”
A guilty person will most likely become highly distressed with prolonged pauses in the conversation and may speak more than normal, adding unnecessary details in order to avoid silence. They may also attempt to be humorous or sarcastic in an effort to try to avoid uncomfortable subjects.
Accuracy in assessing body language usually falls within the 50% range, however even good liars usually cannot consciously control all of the different aspects of body language that indicate deception. Often when we “instinctively” know that a person is lying to us, it is actually our subconscious mind ascertaining and assimilating subtle cues in a person’s body language that indicate a lie has taken place. Although we would all love to know when somebody is telling the truth or lying, the fact is that there are no infallible methods. Using the principles of kinetics in evaluating people can be helpful and insightful but use it in conjunction with common sense when drawing conclusions.
A particularly insightful article, I think cognisance has been
taken of both verbal and non-verbal clues. It would be interesting
to know if the writer has factored some NLP (Neuro-Linguistic
Programming) into the observations made, where eye movement can
play a significant role. Also of the validity of the observations
made have been extended into using other modalities such as
Handwriting Analysis.
Posted 33 months ago
Good article and excellent comment Colin. How does it go again?
Up and to the left, and down to the right...Which is lying and
which is recollecting? Btw...I came to this article through Colin's
tweet, and plan to go back and follow you both, here on FTZ and on
Twitter...See it works! But like Sara Valor says... "Ya gotta work
it!"
Posted 32 months ago
Tom
While these can help to indicate when someone is lying, isn't it
equally possible that the person being 'profiled' is simply nervous
and/or fidgety?
Absolutely valid point, Tom. There are currently no infallible
methods of detecting lies and any clues obtained from an
individual's body language would definitely have to be compared
with the same individual's baseline behavior.
Topic: Psychology & Self-Help
Sub-Topic: Body Language3,639 views — 4 comments — +8 recommendations
Published on Oct 26, 2009
Last updated on May 16, 2012
x
Get answers from experts on Knoji. For the best response, be clear in your wording, include all necessary details and avoid spelling and punctuation errors.
Ask a question
x
will be notified of your question.
Your question will also be posted as a public question in the Knoji forums, so be sure to phrase it as a general question that anyone could answer. Personal questions and private messages should be sent using the Message Me feature instead.
Confirm your recommendation
x
By making this recommendation, you are confirming that you would recommend Melissa Murphy to people you know as an expert in the topic Body Language.
Confirm and recommendCancel
You have used your question credit for today. Please wait until midnight today for your question credits to renew.
x
To maintain a high standard for new discussions started, each Knoji member is limited to a certain number of questions each day. Use your questions wisely, ask quality questions and you'll get quality answers.
Credits refresh at midnight US Central time, at which time you'll receive your next day's allotment of credits.
Oops, you haven't confirmed your email yet
x
We've sent an email to your registration email address. You'll need to click the link in that email before you can post stuff on Knoji.
Didn't get the email? First, try checking your spam inbox. If you can't find it, click here and we'll resend your confirmation link.
Thanks for registering!
xWe've sent a confirmation link to your email address. Go to your email and click the link to confirm. Your postings on Knoji will be hidden from public view until you do so.
Didn't get the email? First, try checking your spam inbox. If you can't find it, click here and we'll resend your confirmation link.
Great! Here's a preview of your question.
x
We've sent a confirmation link to your registration email address. Please click this link to confirm your email.
Your question will not be posted publicly until you confirm your email.
Didn't get the email? First, try checking your spam inbox. If you can't find it, click here and we'll resend your confirmation link.
Your confirmation email has been resent
x
Please check your email (check your spam inbox too) and click on the link provided to confirm your account with Knoji.
You have received 0 answer votes on Knoji
x
When people like the answers you provide, they make a public acknowledgement by placing a vote for your answer. The more votes you accumulate on Knoji, the higher you move up in rank. Increased rank gives you increased capabilities, more perks and more expert cred around the site.
Answer questions nowLearn more about user levels
Oops, you're out of question credits for today!
x
We limit the number of questions members can ask on Knoji each day in order to improve the quality of questions and answers. Your question credits will reset each day at midnight US Central time, so come back then to ask more questions!
Contributors on Knoji are awarded Levels as they establish themselves as experts within the community. There are three ways in which users can increase their level, via writing articles or via answering questions, or both.
Level
Article Track
Answer Track
Combined Track
Abilities
Member
-
-
-
Can publish articles, ask and answer questions
Contributor
Successfully publish first article
Must earn +50 votes
Publish first article OR +50 answer votes
Eligible for revenue sharing. Access to Dashboard.
Expert
Must publish 10 consecutive articles
Must earn +200 votes
10 articles OR +200 answer votes
Self-publish and edit past articles. Increased compensation rate.
Guide
Must earn +500 recommendations
Must earn +1,000 votes
+250 article recommendations AND +500 answer votes
Increased earnings rate. Greater number of votes.
Authority
Must earn +1,000 recommendations
Must earn +5,000 votes
+500 article recommendations AND +2,500 answer votes
Increased earnings rate. Greater number of votes & question credits.
Pro
Must earn +5,000 recommendations
Must earn +10,000 votes
+2,500 article recommendations AND +5,000 answer votes
Increased earnings rate. Greater number of votes.
Master
Must earn +10,000 recommendations
Must earn +50,000 votes
+5,000 article recommendations AND +25,000 answer votes
A particularly insightful article, I think cognisance has been taken of both verbal and non-verbal clues. It would be interesting to know if the writer has factored some NLP (Neuro-Linguistic Programming) into the observations made, where eye movement can play a significant role. Also of the validity of the observations made have been extended into using other modalities such as Handwriting Analysis.